Choosing between the Brooklyn Bedding Plank Firm Luxe and the Serta iComfort Elana Firm can be challenging because both are premium mattresses designed for sleepers who want excellent support, pressure relief, and cooling comfort. However, they achieve these goals in very different ways.
The Brooklyn Bedding Plank Firm Luxe is an extra-firm hybrid mattress with a flippable design, while the Serta iComfort Elana is a firm all-memory foam mattress focused on pressure relief and motion isolation. Here’s a detailed comparison to help you decide which one fits your sleeping style.
Why Search Everywhere? Use Comparly for Your Next Comparison.
Quick Decision: Brooklyn Bedding vs Serta iComfort Mattress
Buy the Brooklyn Bedding Plank if:
- You want the firmest mattress available with hybrid support.
- You suffer from lower back pain and need excellent spinal alignment.
- You want a flippable mattress with two firmness options.
- You sleep hot and prefer coil airflow.
- You need high weight capacity and long-term durability.
Buy the Serta iComfort Elana if:
- You prefer the body-hugging feel of memory foam.
- Motion isolation is your top priority.
- You mainly sleep with a partner.
- You want excellent pressure relief for joints.
- You prefer a slightly softer firm feel.
Brooklyn Bedding vs Serta iComfort Mattress: Specs Comparison
Feature | Brooklyn Bedding | Serta iComfort |
Mattress Type | Hybrid | Memory Foam |
Thickness | 13 inches | 11.5 inches |
Firmness | Extra Firm (10/10), Flippable to Medium-Firm | Firm |
Cooling | Optional GlacioTex Cooling Cover + Coil Airflow | CoolFeel Fabric + Graphite Memory Foam |
Motion Isolation | Very Good | Excellent |
Pressure Relief | Excellent | Excellent |
Warranty | Limited Warranty | Limited Warranty |
Best For | Back sleepers, stomach sleepers, heavier sleepers, back pain | Couples, back sleepers, motion isolation lovers |
Price | $1,499 | $1,399 |
Which Is Better Brooklyn Bedding or Serta Mattress?
Overall, Brooklyn Bedding Plank Firm Luxe is the better mattress for most buyers.
Although it costs about $100 more, it delivers significantly more versatility with its flippable construction, hybrid support system, exceptional lumbar support, higher durability, stronger edge support, and industry-leading firmness. It also offers superior airflow thanks to individually wrapped coils and an optional cooling cover.
The Serta iComfort Elana remains an excellent memory foam mattress, especially for couples who value motion isolation and pressure relief, but it lacks the responsiveness, durability, and customization offered by the Brooklyn Bedding mattress.
Winner: Brooklyn Bedding Plank Firm Luxe ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Top 3 Reasons to Choose Brooklyn Bedding Plank Firm Luxe
1. Two Firmness Levels in One Mattress
Unlike the Serta, the Plank Firm Luxe is flippable. One side delivers an ultra-firm feel, while the other provides a firm-medium experience. This flexibility extends the mattress’s lifespan and allows sleepers to adjust firmness if their comfort preferences change.
2. Superior Back Support
The American Chiropractic Association found that the Plank Firm Luxe reduces spinal stress, improves lumbar support, and helps alleviate back pain. Combined with individually wrapped coils, it keeps the spine aligned without excessive sinkage.
3. Better Cooling and Durability
Its hybrid construction naturally allows greater airflow than all-foam mattresses. The optional GlacioTex cooling cover further enhances temperature regulation, making it a better choice for hot sleepers.
Want to compare more products like this? Use Comparly for Your Next Comparison.
Design & Build Quality
These mattresses represent two different construction philosophies.
The Brooklyn Bedding Plank Firm Luxe uses a premium hybrid design combining individually encased steel coils with multiple foam comfort layers. The mattress stands approximately 13 inches tall and features a flippable construction, allowing users to choose between an ultra-firm side and a medium-firm side. This unique design not only offers versatility but also increases longevity since both sleeping surfaces can be used over time. It is also fiberglass-free, GREENGUARD Gold certified, and made using CertiPUR-US certified foams, adding confidence in material safety and indoor air quality.
The Serta iComfort Elana features a traditional five-layer memory foam construction with an 11.5-inch profile. It uses Perfect Conform Memory Foam for body contouring and a supportive foam base designed to maintain spinal alignment. Since it is an all-foam mattress, it has no steel coils, resulting in a more uniform sleeping surface with minimal bounce.
Overall, Brooklyn Bedding offers a more premium and versatile construction.
Winner: Brooklyn Bedding
Firmness & Overall Comfort
Firmness is where these mattresses differ the most.
The Plank Firm Luxe is one of the firmest mattresses available today, rated around 10/10 on the firmness scale. For sleepers who find this too firm, flipping the mattress reveals a medium-firm side. This adaptability makes it suitable for a wider range of sleepers while still maintaining outstanding support.
The Serta iComfort Elana provides a conventional firm feel. Its memory foam contours closely to the body, creating a supportive yet cushioned sensation. While firm, it still allows noticeable sinkage around the shoulders and hips compared to the Plank Firm Luxe.
Back and stomach sleepers who want maximum support are likely to prefer Brooklyn Bedding, while those who enjoy a bit more contouring may favor Serta.
Winner: Brooklyn Bedding
Pressure Relief
Pressure relief is essential for reducing discomfort around the shoulders, hips, and lower back.
The Brooklyn Bedding Plank Firm Luxe combines responsive foams with individually wrapped coils, creating targeted pressure relief without sacrificing support. Because the surface remains highly supportive, the hips stay elevated, reducing spinal stress.
The Serta iComfort Elana excels in this category due to its Perfect Conform Memory Foam. It gently cradles pressure points and evenly distributes body weight, making it particularly comfortable for people with sensitive joints.
If pure cushioning is your priority, the Serta performs exceptionally well.
Winner: Serta iComfort
Cooling Performance
Cooling is another major difference.
The Brooklyn Bedding Plank Firm Luxe benefits from open coil construction that naturally promotes airflow throughout the mattress. Buyers can also choose the GlacioTex cooling cover, which feels cool to the touch and helps dissipate body heat quickly.
The Serta iComfort Elana relies on CoolFeel Fabric and graphite-infused memory foam to pull heat away from the sleeper. While these features improve cooling compared to standard memory foam, all-foam mattresses generally retain more heat than hybrid models.
For consistently cooler sleep, Brooklyn Bedding has the advantage.
Winner: Brooklyn Bedding
Motion Isolation
Couples often prioritize motion isolation to avoid being disturbed by a partner’s movements.
The Serta iComfort Elana performs exceptionally well because memory foam absorbs movement extremely effectively. Whether one partner changes positions or gets out of bed, very little motion transfers across the mattress.
The Plank Firm Luxe also performs well due to individually wrapped coils and foam layers, but its responsive hybrid construction creates slightly more movement than dense memory foam.
Winner: Serta iComfort
Edge Support
Strong edge support increases the usable sleeping surface and makes getting in and out of bed easier.
Brooklyn Bedding’s hybrid construction provides noticeably firmer edges thanks to its steel coil support system. Sitting or sleeping near the edge feels secure with minimal compression.
The all-foam Serta compresses more when weight is placed on the perimeter, resulting in weaker edge stability.
Winner: Brooklyn Bedding
Back Pain & Spinal Alignment
Both mattresses target spinal support, but Brooklyn Bedding has a distinct advantage.
The Plank Firm Luxe was specifically engineered for spinal alignment and has been evaluated by the American Chiropractic Association, which found improvements in lumbar support and reductions in spinal stress during testing. The combination of firm support and responsive coils helps keep the spine in a neutral position.
The Serta iComfort Elana uses its 5 ZoneResponse support design to reinforce key areas of the body and maintain alignment. It provides good support, but the deeper contouring of memory foam may allow slightly more sinkage for heavier sleepers.
For those seeking maximum support for back pain, Brooklyn Bedding is the stronger choice.
Winner: Brooklyn Bedding
Durability
Hybrid mattresses typically outlast all-foam models because steel coils maintain their shape longer than dense foam cores.
The Plank Firm Luxe uses individually encased coils, high-density foams, and a flippable design that helps distribute wear evenly across both sleeping surfaces, extending its lifespan.
The Serta iComfort Elana is built with quality materials and should provide many years of reliable performance, but memory foam naturally softens with long-term use and cannot be flipped.
Winner: Brooklyn Bedding
Trial Period & Value
Brooklyn Bedding includes a 120-night sleep trial, while Serta offers a 100-night trial.
Although Brooklyn Bedding costs about $100 more, buyers receive a flippable mattress, hybrid construction, greater durability, stronger edge support, better cooling, and two firmness options in one product. These additional features provide excellent long-term value.
Serta remains competitively priced and offers strong comfort, particularly for memory foam enthusiasts.
Winner: Brooklyn Bedding
Final Verdict
Both mattresses are excellent, but they cater to different types of sleepers.
Choose the Brooklyn Bedding Plank Firm Luxe if you want an extra-firm hybrid mattress with exceptional spinal support, superior cooling, excellent durability, strong edge support, and the flexibility of two firmness options in one mattress. It is particularly well suited for back sleepers, stomach sleepers, heavier individuals, and anyone dealing with chronic lower back pain.
Choose the Serta iComfort Elana if you prefer the classic body-contouring feel of memory foam, outstanding motion isolation, and gentle pressure relief. It is an excellent option for couples and sleepers who enjoy a supportive yet slightly cushioned firm surface.
Overall Winner: Brooklyn Bedding Plank Firm Luxe
Its hybrid construction, flippable firmness, advanced cooling, stronger edge support, higher weight capacity, longer trial period, and clinically recognized spinal support make it the more versatile and better overall mattress for most sleepers.
