The Brother MFC-L5915DW and Brother MFC-L5710DW are two high-performance monochrome laser all-in-one printers designed for busy offices and workgroups. Both offer fast printing speeds, duplex printing, wireless networking, advanced scanning features, and excellent reliability for business environments.
While the two printers share many similarities, the MFC-L5915DW targets higher-volume offices with faster printing, a larger automatic document feeder, a bigger touchscreen, and support for ultra-high-yield toner cartridges. The MFC-L5710DW is a more affordable option that still delivers excellent performance and productivity features for small to medium-sized businesses.
Why Search Everywhere? Use Comparly for Your Next Comparison.
Quick Decision: Brother MFC-L5915DW vs MFC-L5710DW
- 👉 Buy the Brother MFC-L5915DW if you want the fastest 50 PPM printing, a larger 70-sheet automatic document feeder, a premium 5-inch color touchscreen, support for ultra-high-yield 18,000-page toner cartridges, and lower long-term operating costs for busy offices with high monthly print volumes.
- 👉 Buy the Brother MFC-L5710DW if you want a more affordable business laser printer with nearly identical 48 PPM performance, faster duplex scanning, advanced scan-to-email and scan-to-cloud workflows, editable Microsoft Office document conversion, and excellent overall value for small and medium-sized businesses.
Brother MFC-L5915DW vs MFC-L5710DW Printer Printer: Specs Comparison
Feature | Brother MFC-L5915DW | Brother MFC-L5710DW |
Printer Type | Monochrome Laser All-in-One | Monochrome Laser All-in-One |
Functions | Print, Copy, Scan | Print, Copy, Scan |
Print Speed | 50 ppm | 48 ppm |
Auto Duplex Printing | Yes | Yes |
ADF Capacity | 70 Sheets | 50 Sheets |
Display | 5-inch Color Touchscreen | Color Touchscreen |
Toner Support | TN920UXXL (18,000 pages) | TN920XXL (11,000 pages) |
Weight | 38.3 lbs | 36 lbs |
Price | $589 | $499 |
🏆 Which is Better Brother MFC-L5915DW or MFC-L5710DW?
The Brother MFC-L5915DW is the better printer overall because it offers faster 50 ppm printing, a larger 70-sheet automatic document feeder, a premium 5-inch touchscreen, and support for ultra-high-yield 18,000-page toner cartridges that significantly reduce operating costs in high-volume offices.
However, the Brother MFC-L5710DW is the better value option for most small and medium businesses because it delivers nearly identical performance, slightly faster duplex scanning, advanced document conversion features, and saves about $90 upfront.
Top 3 Reasons to Pick the Brother MFC-L5915DW
- Faster 50 ppm print speed for high-volume environments.
- Larger 70-sheet automatic document feeder.
- Supports 18,000-page ultra-high-yield toner for lower long-term printing costs.
Want to compare more products like this? Use Comparly for Your Next Comparison.
Design & Build Quality
The Brother MFC-L5915DW is built for demanding office environments. It features a larger chassis and weighs 38.3 pounds, reflecting its heavy-duty design and higher paper-handling capabilities. The printer feels robust and engineered for continuous business use.
The MFC-L5710DW is slightly more compact and lighter at 36 pounds. Its smaller footprint makes it easier to place in smaller offices while still maintaining the solid construction Brother laser printers are known for.
For larger workgroups and intensive use, the MFC-L5915DW feels more enterprise-oriented.
Winner: Brother MFC-L5915DW
Print Speed & Performance
Print speed is one of the key differences between these two printers.
The MFC-L5915DW delivers up to 50 pages per minute, making it one of the fastest monochrome laser all-in-one printers in its class. Large reports, invoices, and business documents are completed quickly, helping maintain productivity during busy periods.
The MFC-L5710DW prints at up to 48 pages per minute. While only slightly slower, the difference can add up in offices printing thousands of pages monthly.
Both printers produce sharp, professional-quality monochrome documents with excellent text clarity.
Winner: Brother MFC-L5915DW
Printing Costs & Toner Efficiency
For businesses concerned about long-term operating expenses, toner capacity is extremely important.
The MFC-L5915DW supports Brother’s TN920UXXL ultra-high-yield toner cartridge capable of printing up to 18,000 pages. This dramatically lowers cost per page and reduces toner replacement frequency.
The MFC-L5710DW supports the TN920XXL super high-yield toner cartridge rated for 11,000 pages. While still highly economical, it cannot match the efficiency of the MFC-L5915DW.
Businesses with heavy monthly print volumes will see meaningful savings from the larger toner capacity of the MFC-L5915DW.
Winner: Brother MFC-L5915DW
Scanning Performance
Both printers feature single-pass duplex scanning, allowing both sides of a page to be scanned simultaneously.
The MFC-L5915DW offers scanning speeds up to 56 images per minute and includes a larger 70-sheet automatic document feeder, making it excellent for processing large batches of documents.
The MFC-L5710DW actually has a slight advantage in scanning speed, reaching up to 60 images per minute. Although its ADF holds only 50 sheets, the faster scanning speed can help users digitize documents slightly quicker.
For raw scan speed, the MFC-L5710DW wins, while the MFC-L5915DW handles larger batches more efficiently.
Winner: Brother MFC-L5710DW
Automatic Document Feeder & Document Handling
Document handling is a major productivity factor in office printers.
The MFC-L5915DW features a 70-sheet automatic document feeder, allowing larger scanning, copying, and digitization jobs to be completed with less user intervention.
The MFC-L5710DW includes a 50-sheet ADF, which is sufficient for most offices but requires more frequent reloading when handling larger document stacks.
High-volume users will appreciate the additional capacity of the MFC-L5915DW.
Winner: Brother MFC-L5915DW
Connectivity & Network Features
Both printers are well-equipped for modern offices.
Each model includes:
- Gigabit Ethernet
- Dual-band Wi-Fi
- USB connectivity
- Mobile printing support
- Wireless scanning
- Cloud connectivity
Whether deployed in a wired office network or wireless environment, both printers offer excellent flexibility and easy integration.
There is no meaningful difference in connectivity performance.
Winner: Tie
Touchscreen & Ease of Use
The MFC-L5915DW features a large 5-inch color touchscreen that provides a premium user experience. Navigation is intuitive, and frequently used workflows can be customized for quicker access.
The MFC-L5710DW also includes a touchscreen interface but lacks the larger display offered by the MFC-L5915DW.
Users who frequently access cloud services, scan destinations, and advanced settings will appreciate the larger screen.
Winner: Brother MFC-L5915DW
Advanced Scanning & Workflow Features
The MFC-L5710DW includes particularly strong workflow tools for office users. It can scan directly to email, cloud services, SharePoint, SFTP servers, and create searchable and editable Microsoft Office documents.
The MFC-L5915DW also supports cloud scanning and USB workflows but places more emphasis on speed, capacity, and high-volume productivity.
Organizations focused on document management and digital workflows may find the MFC-L5710DW’s software capabilities especially useful.
Winner: Brother MFC-L5710DW
Office Productivity
For demanding workgroups, the MFC-L5915DW is the stronger productivity machine. Faster printing, larger ADF capacity, bigger touchscreen, and lower operating costs make it more suitable for busy departments and larger offices.
The MFC-L5710DW remains an excellent performer and can easily handle the needs of most small and medium-sized businesses.
Winner: Brother MFC-L5915DW
Price & Value for Money
The MFC-L5710DW costs approximately $90 less than the MFC-L5915DW while retaining most of the same core functionality.
For many businesses, the difference between 48 ppm and 50 ppm will be negligible, making the MFC-L5710DW an outstanding value.
The MFC-L5915DW justifies its higher price through better toner economy, larger ADF capacity, and enhanced user experience.
Small businesses will likely get better value from the MFC-L5710DW, while larger offices will benefit from the MFC-L5915DW’s higher productivity.
Winner: Brother MFC-L5710DW
Final Verdict
The Brother MFC-L5915DW is the better printer overall thanks to its faster 50 ppm print speed, larger 70-sheet automatic document feeder, premium 5-inch touchscreen, and support for ultra-high-yield 18,000-page toner cartridges that significantly reduce long-term printing costs.
Choose the Brother MFC-L5915DW if you run a busy office, print thousands of pages each month, or need the lowest possible cost per page.
Choose the Brother MFC-L5710DW if you want nearly the same performance at a lower price and prefer better overall value for a small or medium-sized business.
